216.696.8700

Data Centers and Ohio Townships Part 2: What Happens After the Trustees Vote

November 17, 2026
NCAA

Part Two of a two-part series. This article reflects developments as of November 11, 2026, including preliminary results of the November 3, 2026 general election. Further action by the General Assembly during its post-election session, which runs through mid-December, may change the analysis below.

In Part One of this series, we explored the moratoriums and zoning changes Ohio townships have adopted in response to data center proposals. A temporary pause eventually requires a decision about whether, and on what conditions, a data center may proceed. Either way, the vote is rarely the end of the dispute. What comes next depends heavily on two things: the form the trustees’ decision takes, and a township referendum process that has changed significantly over the past three years.

The Township Zoning Referendum

When trustees adopt an amendment to a township’s zoning resolution, the amendment takes effect 30 days later unless, within that window, residents present a petition signed by registered electors in the zoned area equal to at least 35% of the total vote cast for governor in that area at the most recent gubernatorial election. If the petition is valid, the amendment goes on the ballot at the next primary or general election held at least 90 days after the petition is filed, and it cannot take effect unless a majority of voters approve it.

The petition must also identify and summarize the amendment and be accompanied by an appropriate map of the affected area. Amendments establishing or modifying planned-unit development regulations also have special signature-validation procedures under R.C. 519.12(J)(2). Those technical requirements are frequently contested, and the Supreme Court of Ohio regularly resolves protests over township referendum petitions on an expedited basis, as it did earlier this year in a dispute arising from Ottawa County.

The more significant challenge is the signature threshold. Until 2023, a township zoning referendum required signatures equal to 8% of the gubernatorial vote. The 2023 state operating budget raised that figure to 15%, and the 2025 operating budget, House Bill 96, raised it again to 35%, effective September 30, 2025, according to the Ohio Secretary of State. A follow-up bill effective September 23, 2026, updated the statutory petition form to match. The practical effect is considerable. In a township where 6,000 votes were cast for governor, opponents of a zoning amendment once needed 480 signatures. Today they need 2,100, gathered within 30 days.

Two further details deserve attention. First, House Bill 96 created an exception for qualifying projects: an amendment related to any property involved in a “megaproject,” as defined in R.C. 122.17, takes effect immediately upon adoption and is exempt from referendum. R.C. 519.12(J)(1). Second, because the threshold is pegged to the most recent gubernatorial election, the November 3 election has reset the baseline. After certification, the signature requirement must be recalculated using the 2026 gubernatorial vote in the affected area; the number may increase or decrease.

The zoning referendum under R.C. 519.12 applies to zoning amendments. Certain resolutions of limited-home-rule townships are subject to a separate referendum procedure under R.C. 504.14. Where a township’s existing zoning already lists data centers as a conditional use, as Shalersville Township’s does, the decision on a particular project typically rests with the township board of zoning appeals under R.C. 519.14, and a challenge proceeds as an administrative appeal to the court of common pleas under R.C. Chapter 2506 rather than at the ballot box. In short, the form of the township’s decision can determine which remedies are available to everyone involved.

When the Trustees Say Yes

For residents who oppose a rezoning or text amendment that clears the way for a data center, the referendum remains the most direct remedy, but it is now considerably harder to use. Gathering signatures equal to 35% of the prior gubernatorial vote in the zoned area in 30 days is a substantial organizing effort, particularly in a large township. When a referendum does qualify, however, the outcome can be decisive. In preliminary November 3 returns, Wilmington voters, acting on four citizen-petitioned referendums, overturned rezonings of nearly 550 acres for data center use with roughly 80% of the vote, and Ashville voters rejected a village agreement with a data center developer by a similar margin. Both were municipal rather than township votes, but they suggest that a data center approval that reaches the ballot faces real risk.

If the project qualifies as a megaproject, a referendum may not be available at all. R.C. 122.17 defines a megaproject through multiple conditions, including a qualifying agreement with the Ohio Tax Credit Authority, specified wage requirements, and a commitment to make at least $1 billion in fixed-asset investments or create at least $75 million in Ohio payroll, subject to statutory adjustment of the dollar thresholds. A projected investment of that size, without the other statutory conditions, is insufficient. The statute requires a qualifying agreement; how the referendum exemption applies to particular data center projects remains unsettled in reported decisions. The Senate substitute for House Bill 646 would prospectively exclude data centers from the statutory megaproject definition. Because R.C. 519.12(J)(1) borrows the R.C. 122.17 definition, that change could also narrow the referendum exemption for future data center projects.

Residents have other options, though each carries its own burdens:

  • Procedural Challenges: C. 519.12 prescribes detailed notice, hearing, and planning commission review requirements, and township boards are subject to Ohio’s Open Meetings Act. Defects in that process can provide grounds for a challenge, as the Perry Township residents discussed in Part One have alleged.
  • Declaratory Judgment: Neighboring owners who can show a concrete injury from a rezoning may challenge its constitutionality in a declaratory judgment action. Zoning legislation is presumed constitutional, however, and a challenger must prove otherwise “beyond fair debate.”
  • Administrative Appeals: Where approval comes through a conditional use permit rather than a zoning amendment, parties directly affected by the decision may appeal it to the court of common pleas under R.C. Chapter 2506.
  • The Political Process: Township trustees are elected, and residents unhappy with zoning decisions can make them an issue at the next trustee election. Pending legislation could also change the math. House Bill 985 would lower the referendum threshold from 35% to 20%. Its sponsor has cited data center disputes as a reason for the bill and has said he hopes to add it to another bill during the post-election session now underway. As of this writing, we are not aware of further action on the bill.

When the Trustees Say No

For a landowner who has signed an option with a data center developer, or for the developer itself, a denial, a definitional ban, or an extended moratorium presents a different set of choices:

  • Check for Vested Rights: If data centers were a permitted use when the owner completed every step required to apply for a permit, the owner may be entitled to have the application decided under the zoning then in effect. Gibson v. City of Oberlin, 171 Ohio St. 1 (1960). The Supreme Court of Ohio recently confirmed the limits of that rule, holding that a developer that had only begun a village’s preliminary site-plan review had no right to proceed once a moratorium took effect. Vested rights also offer little help where the project requires a rezoning, because the decision to amend a zoning resolution is a legislative one that trustees are not obligated to make.
  • Challenge the Township’s Authority: Because townships have only the zoning powers the General Assembly has granted them, a moratorium or ban that exceeds those powers, or that was adopted without following R.C. 519.12, may be vulnerable. The Attorney General has tied the validity of a township moratorium to its terms and the circumstances of its enactment, 2003 Op. Att’y Gen. No. 2003-024, and the Ohio Township Association (the OTA) has itself asked lawmakers for clearer authority. A moratorium adopted by a township with no zoning resolution at all may draw particular scrutiny, although we are not aware of a reported Ohio decision resolving that question in the data center context. Lordstown does not answer it either, because that decision turned on the developer’s lack of a vested right, not on the validity of the village’s moratorium.
  • Challenge the Restriction as Applied: A landowner may seek a declaratory judgment that a township zoning restriction is unconstitutional as applied to its property. The same “beyond fair debate” burden applies, and courts give substantial deference to legislative zoning judgments.
  • Pursue a Takings Claim: A regulation that goes too far may require compensation, and in Ohio a property owner typically seeks that relief through a mandamus action to compel the government to begin appropriation proceedings. State ex rel. Shemo v. Mayfield Hts., 95 Ohio St.3d 59 (2002). A temporary moratorium is not automatically a taking, however. Courts instead weigh the economic impact on the owner, the owner’s investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action. Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, 535 U.S. 302 (2002).
  • Seek Annexation: Owners may seek expedited annexation to an adjacent municipality under R.C. 709.023, if statutory conditions are met, including the consent of all owners and a 500-acre limit. The land remains within the township but becomes subject to municipal zoning. If the land was zoned when annexation was sought, the municipality must require a buffer when it determines that newly permitted uses are clearly incompatible with those permitted on adjacent township land. C. 709.023(C). Annexation helps only if the municipality wants the project. Grove City’s law director, for example, has said the city’s code does not allow data centers, and on November 3, Grove City voters approved a charter amendment requiring voter approval for developments occupying 50 or more contiguous acres, drawing more than 20 megawatts at peak capacity, or using more than 500,000 gallons of water a day. Similarly, Niles adopted its own moratorium after a developer sought to annex land from Weathersfield Township. The OTA has also flagged annexation as a pathway around township decisions, and a pending bill, House Bill 829, would halt expedited annexations of this kind when a township objects.
  • Work Within the Process: Many disputes end in negotiation rather than litigation. Conditional use standards addressing noise, water, lighting, and on-site power infrastructure can give a township meaningful oversight while leaving a path for a project that meets them, as the ongoing Shalersville discussions illustrate.

Practical Considerations for Landowners and Developers

Given this uncertainty, parties to a potential data center transaction should build zoning risk into their agreements from the start:

  • Check the Zoning Status: Confirm whether the township is zoned; whether data centers are permitted, conditional, or undefined; whether a moratorium is pending or in effect; and whether a nearby municipality could provide utilities or annexation, and if so, whether its charter requires voter approval for large projects. Separately, confirm electrical service and interconnection schedules, water and wastewater capacity, and any data center tariff, collateral, or infrastructure cost-sharing obligations.
  • Allow for Time: Option and contingency periods should account for a possible moratorium, the 30-day referendum window, and an election that may fall several months later.
  • Define Final Approval: Zoning contingencies should treat an approval as final only after the referendum period expires or any referendum result is certified, and after any appeal period runs.
  • Allocate Litigation Risk: The agreement should address who controls, funds, and bears the outcome of a referendum campaign, administrative appeal, or lawsuit.

Township officials, for their part, can reduce their own exposure by following the R.C. 519.12 procedures carefully, tying any moratorium to an active and documented study, and setting a defined end date. Any project conditions should be supported by the record and kept within the township’s statutory zoning authority.

Conclusion

Ohio’s township zoning referendum was designed to give residents a check on their trustees. As the threshold has risen and exceptions have been added, that check has become harder to use in either direction. Residents face a steep climb to overturn an approval, and landowners hoping to overturn a ban must persuade the same share of their neighbors. When a data center question does reach the ballot, however, preliminary November 3 returns indicate substantial local support for restrictions. Many disputes are therefore likely to be resolved in court, in negotiations over conditional use standards, or at the Statehouse, with the ballot box serving as a powerful but difficult backstop.

As these rules continue to evolve, KJK’s Real Estate Practice Group can help landowners, developers, and public entities evaluate their options and structure transactions to account for zoning risk. Contact James Scherer (JJS@kjk.com) or Ted Theofrastous (TCT@kjk.com) to learn more.